Hans Andersen's Fairy Tales. Second Series — A Reader’s Guide

  2   1
Andersen, H. C. (Hans Christian), 1805-1875, Stickney, J. H. (Jenny H.), 1840- [Editor], Hart, Edna F. [Illustrator] Project Gutenberg 2010
Fairy tales; Fairy tales -- Denmark; Children's stories, Danish -- Translations into English Readers of public-domain and historical texts
Project Gutenberg digital edition en

Edition facts

Words: 72,107
Reading time: 314 min
Text sections: 9
This second series of Hans Christian Andersen's fairy tales, edited by J. H. Stickney, features 28 stories including 'The Little Mermaid,' 'The Red Shoes,' and 'The Emperor's New Clothes.' The collection showcases Andersen's narrative voice, which shifts between lyrical description, playful dialogue, and moral reflection, often with sudden changes in pace.
Share

Andersen's narrative voice in this second series is remarkably fluid, moving without warning from the intimate, conversational tone of a storyteller addressing children to the detached, almost reportorial language of a folklorist. In 'The Flax,' the plant's exuberant first-person declarations—'How fortunate I am! It makes me so happy'—give way abruptly to the fern's mournful 'Snip, snap' song, a shift that signals the tale's turn toward loss and transformation. This technique recurs throughout the collection: a buoyant opening often yields to a somber or ironic conclusion, as in 'The Little Mermaid' and 'The Red Shoes.' The editor, J. H. Stickney, has selected stories that highlight these tonal contrasts, pairing whimsical premises with unexpectedly grave outcomes.

Shifting Perspectives and Unreliable Narrators

Andersen frequently changes the focal point of his narratives, sometimes within a single paragraph. In 'The Flax,' the story begins with the flax's own voice, then shifts to the fern's commentary, and later to an omniscient narrator who describes the flax's destruction and rebirth as linen. This technique creates a layered effect: the reader is never allowed to settle into a single viewpoint. In 'Soup from a Sausage Skewer,' the mouse narrator admits, 'I fancied, as so many of my age do, that I already knew everything—but it was not so.' This self-deprecating admission undercuts the authority of the first-person account, reminding the reader that the tale is filtered through a fallible consciousness. The effect is to make the fantastic elements—talking plants, mice, and elves—feel both immediate and uncertain, as if the story itself might change its mind.

Pace and the Interruption of Lyrical Passages

Andersen's pacing is deliberately uneven. He often interrupts a lyrical description with a sudden, almost jarring shift to dialogue or action. In 'The Flax,' the opening paragraph luxuriates in the beauty of the blue flowers 'as delicate as the wings of a moth,' but the next line cuts to the flax's boastful speech. Similarly, in 'Soup from a Sausage Skewer,' the mouse's travel narrative is punctuated by sensory details—'the forest smelt so strong that I sneezed and thought of sausage'—that break the flow of the journey with a comic, earthy note. These interruptions prevent the stories from becoming too sentimental or too moralistic. They also mirror the way children's attention wanders: a moment of wonder is followed by a joke, a threat, or a change of scene. The result is a reading experience that feels alive and unpredictable, as if the tale is being told aloud by a performer who adjusts his tone to keep his audience engaged.

The Role of the Editor and the Selection's Structure

J. H. Stickney's editorial choices shape the collection's overall pace and voice. The preface notes that these stories are 'the best for children's use,' implying a deliberate selection from Andersen's larger body of work. The arrangement of tales—from the lighthearted 'The Flax' to the tragic 'The Little Mermaid' to the satirical 'The Emperor's New Clothes'—creates a rhythm of rising and falling emotional intensity. Stickney also includes notes at the end of the volume, which provide brief contextual or explanatory remarks. These notes, though sparse, serve as a quiet counterpoint to the stories themselves, offering a more scholarly perspective that contrasts with Andersen's folkloric tone. The presence of an editor's hand is felt in the careful ordering of tales, which avoids monotony by alternating between stories with happy endings and those with bittersweet or cautionary conclusions.

Readers approaching this collection should pay attention to the moments when the narrative voice shifts—when a character's boast is undercut by a sudden event, or when a lyrical passage gives way to blunt dialogue. These transitions are where Andersen's artistry is most apparent. The stories reward rereading, as the changes in pace and perspective often reveal new layers of meaning. Whether read aloud or silently, the tales invite the reader to notice not just what happens, but how the telling itself shapes the experience.

Related eBooks